Is the Brawler’s Guild Great, Awful, Or A Bit Of Both?

by on December 5, 2012


We’ve never seen anything like the Brawler’s Guild in WoW. And that means no-one’s quite sure what to make of it.

Is it the best thing since sliced bread? We’ve heard that it is. Is it the worst thing since sliced – er – people? We’ve heard that too.

Today Apple Cider’s weighing in with a long, thoughtful post that concludes that, well, it’s a bit of both – but mostly a brave new step for WoW -

” When Blizzard first announced this feature, I was excited. I loved soloing things! I really enjoyed being able to outlive and survive something incredibly big. Even though I was slightly squishy on my mage, I was a pretty veteran player and could keep up. I even had entire alts developed towards being able to solo stuff as well. The idea of being a non-traditional (see: Not a Death Knight) soloer is something I’ve always enjoyed.

Then all the drawbacks came in – invites would be sold via the Black Market Auction House. It would be open to a very select group of people at first. It was difficult in nature. It would be a queued line. And originally, that it had spectators and they were allowed to toss buffs or debuffs at you. This made me lose all interest in competing at first. The idea that your skill mattered very little if you were someone that would earn a lot of buffs or debuffs galled me in terms of having it be pure display of your ability to solo stuff. Having spectators made me a little queasy in terms of possible jeering as well. Thankfully, they removed the buffs/debuffs thing early on, but it still left a bad taste in my mouth. This wasn’t necessarily the soloing challenge I had in mind, and it seemed to me that it was geared towards a different sort of people. An affluent, fairly well-geared person that enjoyed putting on a show. It was very gladiatorial in that aspect and I never considered myself as such. So in my mind, it would attract at first just the top-end raider types on my server who made most of their gold selling heroic Deathwing mount runs or something of that nature. I’d never be able to afford an invite, I’d never get in, and if I did, I’d be boo’ed to hell and back.

Curiously, I found myself sitting at the Black Market Auction House even still, chasing around bids as they spiraled up and up. I managed to scoot away with one for 60k, very pricey for the privilege of getting in on this on the first day, but with the same feeling of excitement nonetheless. What was wrong with me? Didn’t I already eschew the idea of the people getting into the Brawler’s Guild?”

Apple Cider tells the rest of her story – from the highs of the first days to the low of griefers and idiots arriving – and comes to some very interesting conclusions.

So, what do you think about the Brawler’s Guild so far?

If you enjoyed this article, check out our other posts from these categories: World of Warcraft

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Paul December 6, 2012 at 12:38 am

I’m completely ignoring it. It has no effect on my gameplay whatsoever.

Reply

Vince December 9, 2012 at 11:36 pm

I’m having fun with it. Got to rank 4 and got my Clock’em pet. =)

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: