Is raiding becoming a closed club – follow-up

Tobold’s posted a follow-up article to his comment on raiding yesterday, and the quote he pulls from one of his commenters, Samus, really hit home with one of my current feelings about raid design.

Current raid design is based around individual mistakes leading to full scale failure for everyone. This is obviously going to lead to the exclusion of people who are more prone to mistakes. This is what raiding IS. The entire concept is high level perfectionism.

But does it have to be?

This is my current biggest problem with raiding in WoW – it seems the only way to make it harder, in the developers’ eyes, is to demand performance that is increasingly perfect, over increasingly long periods of time. Fairly trivial mechanics (“Press an ability button NOW!”, “move out of this area NOW!”) are made harder by shorter timeframes to complete them and reduced margins for error – and that’s it. Nearly all of the current raid content that I’ve seen would be better handled by a decently programmed bot, with lightning reflexes and no concentration to worry about, than by a human with the ability to adapt, improvise, and learn on the fly.

Is that really all we can manage? Reflex and concentration checks? Or could raiding challenge other things too – improvisation ability, lateral thinking, tactical play, decision-making, teamwork?

What do you think?

Quote taken from Tobold’s post at

Find all of Tobold’s writing at